A trusted name in frozen treats, Wells Enterprises—also known as Wells Dairy—has issued a voluntary recall of 22 ice cream and frozen yogurt varieties across the U.S. The reason? Possible plastic contamination that could pose a safety risk to consumers.

Well Enterprises, the maker of Blue Bunny, Halo Top and more, has recalled over 17,000 tubs of 3-gallon ice cream products over concerns about the presence of plastic.